New Book Explores Problems of the American College System

higher-education-bookThe authors of a new book, Higher Education? How Colleges Are Wasting Our Money and Failing Our Kids and What We Can Do About It, hope to bring attention to the problems of the American university system. Andrew Hacker is a professor emeritus at Queens College and Claudia Dreifus is a New York Times writer. They argue that too many top universities choose to focus on prestigious research, rather than high quality teaching.

“Schools get status by bringing on professors who are star researchers, star scholars. That’s all we really know about Caltech or MIT or Stanford,” Hacker told The Atlantic. “We don’t really know about the quality of undergraduate teaching at any of these places, and it’s the students who suffer.” The book argues that top professors spend a disproportionate amout of time working on research projects and teach few classes. “We argue that you can get a better education at second or third tier colleges. Have you ever heard of Linfield? It’s in a little town called McMinnville, Oregon. We were very impressed with the campus. The professors care. They spend time with the students. The same is true in a place called Hendrix College in Arkansas, or Earlham College in Indiana. They provide a good education because they don’t expect professors to do research.”

Hacker and Dreifus also critique the over-professionalization of the college curriculum. The book advocates a strong liberal arts education for all students, and that undergraduates can learn vocational skills later. “When somebody comes out of college at 22 with a bachelor’s degree, what can that person really offer Goldman Sachs or General Electric or the Department of the Interior?” said Hacker. “Besides, young people today are going to live to be 90. There’s no rush. That’s why I say they should take a year to work at Costco, at Barnes & Noble, whatever, a year away from studying, and think about what they really want to do.”

Also Read:

Should Professors Get Bonuses for Good Teaching Evaluations?

College is Yours, in 600 Words or Less is a Fresh College Guide

3 Responses to “New Book Explores Problems of the American College System”

  1. nancyb says:

    In this day and age, these well regarded “second and third tier” schools are also a fabulous financial bargain. Graduating without debt, or with a much lower debt burden, PLUS the kind of education offered by dedicated, caring teachers–now that’s value. I went to a large research campus, and my entire undergraduate experience I now liken to a cattle processing plant. We were herded in, never known to professors, graded by TA’s, and pretty much on our own when it came to figuring stuff out. I might as well have been home-schooled.

  2. PCB says:

    The problem described in this review is not a new issue. At a well known eastern graduate school of business one class of first year students rose up over really bad teaching and got an accounting professor fired during the semester. I know because I was one of those students.

Leave a Reply


We help students find reviews on colleges, get help with student loan refinancing and other resourceful content to help students.

Social Links

© 2018